By that point the temperature had plummeted to -20C (-4°F) and it soon became apparent that Gurtner could go no further.

Gurtner, a native of Salzburg, Austria, described herself as a “winter child” and “mountain person” on social media, though a statement from the public prosecutor’s office, per the NY Post, claims she had little experience with alpine high-altitude tours.

According to local news outlet Heute, Plamberger and Gurtner were stranded from 8 p.m. onward. Plumberger did not make an emergency call, nor did he give any distress signals when police helicopters flew nearby at 10.50 pm.

At 1.35 am, Plumberger called Alpine police but then put his phone on silent mode, per prosecutors. 30 minutes later, he made his way down the mountain to get help, leaving Gurtner where she was. It’s alleged that he failed to move her to a more sheltered location, and even neglected to cover her with an emergency blanket.

Rescue teams were not able to reach Kerstin until the morning after due to extreme winds. She was later found dead just beneath the summit cross.

Ultimately, Plamberger was convicted of gross negligent manslaughter in February 2026. He maintained that “she told me to go” as the reason for leaving her.

Meanwhile, Gurtner’s mother has publicly supporter Plamberger, arguing that it was her daughter’s choice to attempt to scale the mountain at night.

“Kerstin was also out in the mountains at night because she had to work during the day,” she said. “She loved mountain hikes at sunrise and sunset. The two of them were equipped for the night.

“If Kerstin didn’t agree, they wouldn’t have gone on a mountain tour. Therefore, he doesn’t deserve to be held responsible as the guide.”